Bengal Main Minister Mamata Banerjee has introduced ‘entrepreneurship loans’ of up to Rs five lakh to those who have fled Haryana’s Nuh in the wake of the latest violence there. 

The violence at Muslim-bulk Nuh was sparked by assaults on Hindu spiritual processions (go through and ).

The violence led quite a few Bengali Muslim migrants from Bengal who had been engaged as househelps, building employees, ragpickers and day by day wage earners to return to Bengal. 

In accordance to the Bengal government’s evaluation, about 150 migrant personnel and their households — all Muslims from Malda, Murshidabad, North and South Dinajpur and Birbhum districts — have returned to Bengal from Nuh. 

The Chief Minister declared Monday (21 August) that the condition government will extend ‘entrepreneurship loans’ to support the returnees from Nuh to set up their very own organizations in Bengal. 

Banerjee talked about that this was a welfare and humanitarian gesture in the direction of “our Muslim brothers and sisters”. She was addressing a convention of imams and muezzins (guys who simply call out to Muslims for prayers from mosques) in Kolkata, Monday. 

Banerjee had sent a team headed by Trinamool Rajya Sabha MP Samirul Islam to Nuh to put together a ground report on the violence there. 

Islam spoke to leaders of the Muslim local community in Nuh, which is notorious for its large crime amount and is stated to be the den of criminals and gangsters, and reportedly told them that the Trinamool Congress would stand by the Muslim local community at all times. 

Samirul Islam, who was nominated to the Rajya Sabha previous thirty day period, is a college trainer and operates a civil modern society organisation. He submitted his ground report on Nuh to the Chief Minister past 7 days. 

In accordance to condition officers, the loans would be provided beneath the West Bengal Bhabishyat Credit score Card Plan. Under this plan, the condition authorities gives 15 per cent warranty of cash and 85 per cent bank loan assurance.

The bank loan is a soft and subsidised personal loan for small business people and has a pretty minimal charge of fascination. 

No Need to have To Go Out Of Bengal

The Chief Minister explained that these who have returned from Nuh will not have to go to Nuh, or any other point out for that issue, to glimpse for perform. 

“They can established up their possess firms and gain a whole lot in Bengal alone,” reported Banerjee. 

Previously, way too, Banerjee had claimed individuals who migrate out of Bengal in search of get the job done will not have to do so anymore. 

When lakhs of migrants from Bengal had returned to the state during the Covid-induced pandemic, she had claimed that all of them would locate perform in the state. 

The point out authorities had also set up a system to register the migrants and enable them get jobs in the condition. But nothing arrived out of that for the reason that employment possibilities are seriously limited in Bengal. 

Mamata Banerjee experienced also designed a similar assert immediately after the 2 June prepare incident in Odisha’s Balasore district that claimed 294 lives, a lot of of them from Bengal. 

Most of the victims of that catastrophe have been migrant labourers from Bengal heading to other states in look for of function. Banerjee experienced mentioned at that time as well that a substantial amount of work options are opening up in Bengal and persons will no extended have to migrate out of the state. 

Banerjee cited the three financial corridors coming up in the condition and the new coal mining undertaking that she claimed will crank out lakhs of work. 

“Stay back again in Bengal and acquire benefit of the many prospects opening up. No just one demands to go out. Continue to be in Bengal and be safe and sound and prosper,” mentioned Banerjee. 

But the really fact that lakhs of young gentlemen and ladies go out of Bengal in research of careers — both of those menial, semi-expert and experienced, or white, blue or brown collar — negates the main minister’s assertion. 

Mortgage To Returnees From Nuh

But obtaining again to the returnees from Nuh, Mamata Banerjee’s offer you of financial loans to them is problematic for 3 explanations. 

A person, the mortgage present appears to have been designed due to the fact the returnees from Nuh are all Muslims. Experienced all those returnees been non-Muslims, would Mamata Banerjee been so generous with them?

Two, the citizenship of quite a few Muslims who have fled Nuh is uncertain. There have been many allegations that numerous Muslims in Nuh are Rohingyas and unlawful immigrants from Bangladesh. 

Even Haryana point out officers have voiced such allegations, and the Haryana Police lately arrested 17 Rohingyas who experienced absent to Nuh by way of Bengal (also read ). 

As these kinds of, all returnees from Nuh ought to be positioned under the scanner and their documents and antecedents checked totally ahead of any sort of preferential treatment method is prolonged to them. 

Three, the returnees from Nuh are entitled to no exclusive treatment. None of them are victims of violence and have left Nuh on their very own. It is pretty particular that all of them will return to Nuh once more only due to the fact they will find no sources of sustenance in Bengal. 

Entrepreneurial financial loans are readily available to anybody who can persuade lending establishments of a excellent business enterprise strategy. This kind of financial loans ought to be prolonged strictly on merit. 

The Nuh returnees should to have been informed that if they want to commence compact firms on their very own, they can use for loans as a result of the suitable channels and will have to satisfy the established standards to get financial loans. 

Paying taxpayers’ money on appeasement policies is not fantastic governance. It can be securely assumed that there are slender possibilities of the financial loans presented to the returnees ever remaining repaid. 

The financial loans, then, will convert into poor financial loans that will have to be created off. 

But all this seems to make any difference little to Mamata Banerjee who generally destinations her narrow political interests higher than all those of the condition exchequer.